1) What “the threshold” means
The threshold is not “the first time someone sins.” The threshold is the point where a person moves from violating covenant boundaries to rejecting covenant authority.
2) Below the threshold (serious, condemned, but not apostasy)
These are real violations. They can be “abomination” and still not meet the biblical definition of apostasy unless they culminate in denial or allegiance transfer.
| Category | What it looks like | Why it is not apostasy (by itself) |
|---|---|---|
| Sin | Moral failure, temptation, relapse, weakness | No explicit rejection of God’s authority |
| Defilement | Engaging forbidden practices; contamination language | Still not a declared allegiance transfer |
| Heresy risk | Confusion, error, bad reasoning, sloppy categories | Not necessarily taught as “true doctrine” |
| Mockery / theater | Performative provocation without inward denial | Sinful, but not apostasy unless it expresses real denial |
3) Approaching the threshold (the danger zone)
This is where covenant violation begins to evolve into reliance and submission. The key is not “one moment,” but a pattern that reorients trust.
Warning indicators
- Repetition: ongoing consultation (the “familiar” element)
- Reliance: using spirits for guidance, comfort, protection, or benefit
- Authority language: treating a spirit as legitimate source of truth
- Justification: reframing condemned practice as “actually fine”
- Identity fusion: “this defines who I am” rather than “this is a violation”
4) Crossing the threshold (apostasy)
Apostasy occurs when a person knowingly rejects Christ’s authority after receiving knowledge, or transfers allegiance to another spiritual authority.
What crosses the line
- Explicit denial of Christ: public or private repudiation after knowledge
- Allegiance transfer: devotion, vows, submission, or trust placed in another authority
- Participation-as-communion: treating another power as a legitimate “table” (authority participation)
- Finalized repudiation: scorning the covenant as false or irrelevant
5) What does not define the threshold
These things can be sinful, provocative, or deceptive—but they do not mechanically equal apostasy without the decisive elements above.
- Labels: what someone calls themselves
- Ritual mechanics: “un-baptism” as a supposed switch
- Emotions: fear, anger, numbness, spiritual dryness
- Temptation: intrusive thoughts or curiosity
- Being deceived: confusion does not equal willful denial